The personal stories of a few of the thousands of people whose lives have been improved by the Olmstead decision and the Department's Olmstead enforcement work.
In June 2013, the Department reached an Interim Settlement Agreement with the State of Rhode Island and the City of Providence to provide relief to approximately 200 individuals with intellectual and developmental disabilities who received services from the segregated sheltered workshop and day activity service provider Training Through Placement, Inc., and the Harold A. Birch Vocational Program, a special education program which operated a segregated sheltered workshop inside a Providence high school. Under the agreement individuals will receive access to integrated supported employment and integrated day activity services, allowing them to become more active participants in the community. Here are the stories of a few individuals who have already benefited from the agreement.
In 2008, Louis graduated high school with a diploma, but because of a developmental disability that restricts his verbal-motor functions, he was unable to secure long-term integrated employment. His mother Lori - a fierce and devoted advocate for her son—found in a sheltered workshop setting "a closed and protective environment" where Louis "would be among others with similar needs." Louis worked at the sheltered workshop Training Thru Placement ("TTP") for two and a half years, earning well below minimum wage.
When the U.S. Department of Justice reached an agreement with the State of Rhode Island this past summer to transition sheltered workshop participants to integrated employment, Lori objected: "We were very happy with TTP because Louis had work, socialization, and the other clients looked up to him." After some persuasion, however, Fedcap—the agency responsible for transitioning the workshop participants—convinced Lori to explore the option of supported employment.
In October Louis started his new job at Eleanor Slater Hospital, a state hospital, where he utilizes his strong computer skills and passion for mathematics to generate Excel reports, record timesheets, and complete other office-related duties. Louis works at the hospital for forty hours per week. He drives himself to and from work and especially enjoys having his own office, which he has decorated with Red Sox paraphernalia. When asked about challenges that he has faced in his job, Louis jokingly admits that wearing a necktie every day is still somewhat of a struggle.
Seeing her son thrive in the mainstream workforce has dramatically changed Lori's perspective about supported employment. In fact, she recently joined Fedcap/TTP's Board to promote the efforts of community employment for individuals with disabilities.
Looking back Lori admits: "By trying to protect Louis, I was capping him." Lori says that in just a couple of months in his new job "Louis has come out of his shell and his confidence levels are through the roof." Lori was especially touched when, after the Red Sox won the World Series, Louis went out and surprised his father and uncle (also ardent baseball fans) with t-shirts that he purchased with his own money. Louis's job has forever changed the family dynamic and the course of his own life. Now, Lori says, "the sky is the limit."
After graduating from the Birch Vocational High School at the age of 21, Orquideo "Q" went straight into a sheltered workshop, where he earned $2.85 an hour performing piece rate work. He stayed there for eight years.
When the sheltered workshop closed this summer after a settlement agreement between the U.S. Department of Justice and the State of Rhode Island, the provider Fedcap began working with Q to identify job opportunities in competitive industry. Q shared that he had a passion for working with cars, which led to his current employment at Progress Automotive. Q now works in the community for at least thirty hours per week.
Q takes great pride in his work, including car details, oil changes, tire rotations, and worksite maintenance. He catches two buses and is the first to arrive at work every morning. His supervisor, Greg, describes Q's enthusiasm to learn and his willingness to try new things as some of his most valuable assets. After seeing Q work and interact with colleagues and customers, Greg strongly affirmed that there is "no question that Q should be working in the community" rather than a sheltered workshop—"he is a great employee and has continued to grow every single day."
Greg observed early on that he could supply valuable natural supports to Q to ensure his success on the job. To assist Q in making sure his tools were accounted for, Greg devised an easy labeling system for the tools. The system has been so successful that Greg has expanded it to all of his work stations and for all of his employees. Greg highlights this anecdote as just one example of the many benefits that Q has brought to his business.
Cheryl, Q's job coach through Fedcap, facilitated Q's transition into the general workforce. She observed that "community employment has given Q such a sense of pride and accomplishment that he didn't have in the sheltered workshop." Cheryl also notes that, because of the natural supports that have developed at Progress Automotive, her role has already decreased dramatically and she rarely goes to the job site.
Q's competitive income has also afforded him new financial freedoms. With his first paycheck he bought a bed for his dog, which he had wanted to do for some time. And with his next paychecks, he plans to buy shoes and clothes for himself. But to Q, money is not the most important element—when asked what he loves most about his job, he says it's his coworkers: "They make me laugh a lot and they make me feel comfortable—they make me feel like I am a part of them."
For the past thirty years Steven has done what millions of Americans do every day: he gets up early in the morning, goes to work, and earns a paycheck. The fact that Steven has an intellectual disability has never stopped him from seeking to earn a living. But, for most of Steven's life he has had little choice other than to work in a segregated sheltered workshop where he earned well below minimum wage and had little to no contact with non-disabled persons, other than supervising staff.
From 1983-2013, Steven worked at the sheltered workshop and day program provider Training Through Placement, Inc. (TTP), located in a former school building in North Providence, Rhode Island. Steven was one of about 90 people with intellectual and developmental disabilities performing piecework at TTP. There, workers sat along cafeteria-style tables in old classrooms and breezeways, and were assigned tasks such as assembling, sorting, packing, and labeling various products like medical supplies and jewelry. Steven also worked on the facility's "Pandora's Products" line, stuffing peppers, grating cheese, and placing food products in jars.
When Steven first entered TTP, he thought it would be a short stay – just long enough to gain the skills necessary to secure long-term employment in the community. After all, as Steven points out, "the name of the provider is Training Thru Placement." Steven had previously worked in a hardware store after high school and wanted to gain additional skills before returning to the general workforce. But that didn't happen. Because of the lack of State-funded employment services and supports that would have made it possible for him to return to competitive employment, Steven was trapped at TTP for decades.
When he began working at TTP Steven earned approximately $2 an hour. Because TTP held a "special minimum wage" certificate, it was permitted to pay individuals with disabilities sub-minimum wages. These wage rates are based on workers' individual productivity as compared to that of experienced workers without disabilities performing the same work. In spite of his three decades of experience, however, Steven was never promoted and never received a meaningful raise in wage. Thirty years after he began working at TTP, Steven still earned the same wage of approximately $2 per hour—substantially below Rhode Island's minimum wage of $7.75.
Year after year, Steven asked for the services necessary to help him secure integrated employment. No effort was made to assist him in finding a job at a competitive wage that matched his strengths and interests.
All of that is now changing for Steven and the service recipients at TTP. Over the next year the State will provide supported employment services and placements to all people at TTP to help them find, get, keep, and succeed in real jobs. The services will be designed to help people access jobs in typical work settings where they can interact with non-disabled peers and earn at least minimum wage. And when individuals are not working, they will have access to integrated day services. Under the agreement negotiated with the state, individuals like Steven receive supported employment and integrated day services sufficient to support a normative 40 hour work week, with the expectation that individuals will work, on average, in supported employment for at least 20 hours per week.
As a result of the settlement agreement, Steven has finally fulfilled his thirty-year goal of community employment. Steven is flourishing in his new job at Automated Business Solutions, where he works at least twenty hours per week. He enjoys working in an office setting, and because of his effective self-advocacy, he persuaded his employer to provide him with computer training, which will allow him to expand his skill set and advance his career.
Thinking back on his time in the sheltered workshop, Steven noted, "we just did what we thought we were supposed to do, and while we believed that many of us could do more with our lives, we did not know how to make that happen." When asked what it means to Steven to realize his dream of working in the community, Steven responded, "it is a big achievement for me; I've been waiting a long time for this."
Steven is a valuable team member at Automated Business Solutions. The President of the company, Alan, initially did not know what to expect from Steven, but quickly realized he had made a prudent investment: "When you hire someone with disabilities, you think you are helping them out, but no business owner can possibly imagine the benefits that they will receive in return." Reflecting on Steven's dedication, abilities, and successes thus far, Alan says, "I can't help but think if Steve had this opportunity twenty-five years ago, where he'd be today—we are very lucky to have Steve on board."
In October 2010, the United States settled its case against the State of Georgia, resolving claims that persons with mental illness or developmental disabilities were harmed by unnecessary confinement in State hospitals. The State agreed to create meaningful community services systems, including crisis services, case management, housing supports, and other services supporting full integration in daily life for persons with mental illness or developmental disabilities receiving State services. Here are stories of some of the people who have benefitted from the Georgia agreement.
Michael spent years in and out of rehab and battling depression, eventually ending up in a halfway house where he constantly felt unsafe. Michael said he “never had any peace” and he “didn’t care if I died.”
In March, Michael met with a caseworker at AmericanWork, a supported employment program. His caseworker, Jody, helped Michael develop interview skills, work on his resume, and start applying for jobs. Soon after, Michael got a full time job working with inventory at Walmart. He values knowing “when my next paycheck will be” and being able to provide for his own needs. Jody has stayed involved in Michael’s life, checking in on him at least once a week and going out of his way to help him out.
Michael also received a housing voucher which helped him to get his own apartment. Living near work has made it possible for him to keep his job. Beyond that, Michael has loved having his own home. He now has privacy, feels safe, and “I can sleep at night now.” When people ask where he lives, he said “I don’t feel embarrassed anymore.”
Community supports have given Michael some stability and with their help he has rebuilt a life for himself. His depression has improved since he now has a job and “a place to call my own.” Michael has a new sense of purpose and looks forward to each day, saying “I want to wake up every morning now.”
Like many people, John Calvert likes to go swimming. And this summer, there was no shortage of it for the 36-year-old Athens, Ga. resident. He often spent afternoons lounging by the pool in his apartment complex, and he regularly visited a local lakeside recreational area complete with picnic tables, beach, and a small swimming area. John, who has a severe intellectual disability, likes to call it “the ocean.”
Until John moved into his own apartment about two years ago, such summers would not have been possible for him. He had been living at Central State Hospital in Milledgeville, Ga., an institution that served individuals with serious mental health diagnoses and intellectual disabilities. Residents went swimming on occasion, but they had little choice in the matter. They followed the schedule set by staff members, and they went swimming – in groups – only when it was on the agenda for the day. Now, John can swim every day – if he chooses to.
“That’s the biggest difference,” said John’s father, Vaughn. “Now, it’s his choice. If he wants to go swimming, he goes swimming. If he wants to go shopping, he goes shopping.”
He swims, he shops, he sits on his balcony and chats with passersby. Two caregivers, made available through the nonprofit agency Georgia Options, typically stay with John throughout the day to be sure his needs are met. One stays with him during the night. Every other weekend, John visits his parents in Eatonton, 50 miles away. And on weekends when he’s at his apartment, he typically sees his sister, Laura, who lives nearby.
Despite some misgivings about the tremendous transition John made into the community, Vaughn said he’s pleased with where John is now. “We’re happy with where he is, and we’re happy with the way things are going,” he said. “He still has unhappy moments, but overall, he’s happier, calmer, and more at ease because he’s living on his own.”
A simple lunch date at a local restaurant was once unimaginable for Louise Darley and her daughter, Cindy. But now that Cindy lives in a home a mere 20 minutes from her mother, the two have met for lunch weekly, accompanied by Cindy’s ever-present caregivers. One such meeting in late October 2012, when Cindy greeted her mother with a hug, was particularly meaningful for Mrs. Darley. “Cindy had never done that before,” she said. “But since she’s been living nearby and I’m able to see her more, I now believe Cindy knows who I am.”
Cindy, who is 31, has severe developmental delays and needs assistance with many basic tasks. “You can’t ever leave her alone,” her mother said. “She doesn’t know to look both ways before stepping into the street. She doesn’t know to avoid touching a hot stove.”
For years, Mrs. Darley and her husband, Ashley, had cared for their daughter at home, but by the time she was 16 her aggressive behavior had worsened, prompting her parents to place her in state care. Until last year, she was residing in Southwestern State Hospital in Thomasville, Georgia, 85 miles away from her parents’ home in Dawson.
In July of 2011, shortly before her father died, Cindy moved into her current home, which she shares with her caregivers and three roommates. Before the move, her parents had been nervous, fearing she would be subject to abuse in a smaller setting. But now Mrs. Darley couldn’t be happier, and she is especially glad Mr. Darley lived long enough to see Cindy’s new surroundings.
“I just really feel like the Lord has been a part of this process,” she said. “It’s great having Cindy so much closer and being able to see her more often. But my biggest concern is her well-being, and I can see that she’s being taking care of. And she just seems really satisfied. That’s important to me.”
In July 2011, the United States Department of Justice ("DOJ") signed an agreement with Delaware to transform that State's mental health system. The Agreement will help more than 3,000 individuals move into the community and out of Delaware's state operated psychiatric hospital and other state-funded psychiatric facilities or avoid having to enter these institutions to get needed services. Instead, the Agreement is aimed at providing individuals with mental disabilities those necessary supports and services to allow them to live and thrive in the community. Here are the stories of a few of the people who have already benefited from the Agreement.
Michael, 21, has been hospitalized repeatedly and is now successfully working at the International House of Pancakes as a line cook. Michael is a graduate of a culinary program run by Connections, a provider of community mental health and substance abuse services licensed by the Delaware Division of Substance Abuse and Mental Health following the Settlement Agreement. Since October 2011, when the program was established, 90% of the enrollees have been able to obtain employment. Michael, when asked to describe his life now, responded: "I couldn't be any happier than I am now; don't ever see myself going back."
Knicoma is an artist working with the Creative Vision Factory, in Wilmington, Delaware, an art center founded in 2011 to provide individuals with behavioral health disorders an opportunity for self-expression, empowerment, and recovery through its studio and exhibition program. Knicoma was recently selected as an emerging Delaware artist and given a grant through the National Endowment of the Arts. He specializes in drawings in a variety of media. His works confront the evils he sees lurking in today's world and offers a range of redemptive solutions and "ways out." Knicoma believes the messages informing his art assist others in their journey to self-awareness and enlightenment, "to help stop the things that happen over and over again in people's lives – to break the cycle." Knicoma has a strong belief in art's role as a means for social and personal change. "I paint from the experiences I've had." Although he has been hospitalized in psychiatric hospitals in the past, Knicoma now lives on his own. "The person that I am makes the pictures that I make." Asked how the Settlement Agreement affected him, Knicoma responded "Matter of respecting somebody – respect is letting others know that you honor him as a human being."
James, a 48-year-old man, is a recovering drug addict who has depression. He now works as a para-transit driver and as a licensed barber. James provides free haircuts at a local community peer center for individuals who are in recovery. When asked why he provides these services, James answered that "I enjoy helping people and giving back."
Rose is a 65-year-old woman who was formerly homeless. She spent two and a half years at the Delaware Psychiatric Center. She was offered a community placement, due to the agreement, in October 2011. Rose is now living in an apartment and receiving community services, which she describes as “more like life in the past.” Rose says she treasures “being able to go where you want” and “having anyone over without getting someone else’s approval.” She says it is the little things that mean the most. “I now have the right to just live and the freedom to open and close doors.” Rose says, “I love it here,” where “I can have neighbors and friends in the community.” Asked about the differences from the state hospital, Rose said that she “feels a lot safer here” and that she “is no longer scared” and in a “constant threatening situation.” Rose is currently helping organize a women’s wellness group and feels that she now has “the right to just live.” Asked how the settlement agreement affected her life, Rose said: “Thank you for giving me back my life.”
Donald, who has schizophrenia and spent four years at the Delaware Psychiatric Center, has successfully moved to his own apartment, with the help of intensive community services provided under the settlement agreement. He is able to do his own cooking, shopping, and laundry. As Donald says, he is “now treated like everyone else.” He said that, after years in the psychiatric center where all decisions were made for him and life “can break you,” he now feels that “life is going smoothly.” Donald knows his neighbors and has made new friends. Asked about how the settlement agreement affected him, Donald responded: “Independence means being able to accept friendship from other people.” “I’m seen as a together brother.”
In January 2012, the Department reached a settlement agreement with the Commonwealth of Virginia to transform its system for serving people with intellectual and developmental disabilities from one that is heavily reliant on five institutional Training Centers to one that emphasizes community-based services. The agreement, which was approved by the Court in August 2012, will help over 5,000 people move to the community or remain in the community with appropriate supports.
As required under the Agreement, the Commonwealth of Virginia is making community-based settings available to individuals choosing to leave the State’s Training Centers, and other individuals qualifying for, and in urgent need, of community services. The Virginia Board for People with Disabilities prepared a video called Place Matters about individuals who have recently transitioned from Training Centers to the community: http://www.vaboard.org/
Below are the stories of a few people whose lives have been affected by services similar to those that will be provided under the settlement.
Stefon is an 18-year-old with a profound intellectual disability and visual, orthopedic, and language disabilities. Although his support needs are serious, they are all being addressed well in the community. Stefon graduated from his local high school, attended his senior prom, and has won national praise for his participation in Special Olympics. As his mother states, “Stefon is living a meaningful and rich life even though he has profound and multiple disabilities.”
With the supports of Virginia’s Medicaid Waiver for people with intellectual disabilities, Stefon is able to live at home with those who love and support him. As his mother states: “Receiving a Waiver literally changed our lives. Stefon is able to live an independent life doing the things he enjoys . . . My son’s life is significant; he has affected the lives of many people that he has encountered in the community.”
James and Elaine are the parents and legal guardians of Doug, a 41-year-old man with Down syndrome who has serious cognitive disabilities and requires assistance with bathing, dressing and other activities of daily living. Doug lived at the Southeastern Virginia Training Center (“SEVTC”) for 20 years. In 2010, Doug received a Medicaid Waiver and moved to a small group home near his family.
James explains, “I was very afraid when we began to consider community placements for Doug.” While at SEVTC, Doug had to use a wheelchair, but now he walks all the time. After a very smooth transition, Doug no longer needs to eat his meals in a pureed form. He now gets great joy from eating solid foods, especially pancakes, hamburgers, and chocolate cookies. Doug enjoys weekly trips to the bowling alley with his friends, shopping trips, and meals at restaurants in the community. According to James, “quite simply, the services being provided have exceeded my expectations by leaps and bounds, and Doug is happier and more active than I ever imagined was possible.”
Marisa is a 27-year-old with a degree from the Northern Virginia Community College who is now working toward a Social Work degree. Marisa has cerebral palsy, which affects all her limbs and her speech. She uses a power wheelchair to get around and needs assistance with nearly all her physical needs. Before she received a Medicaid Waiver for community-based services, Marisa relied almost entirely on her single mother to provide the physical care she needed. Now she has the supports she needs to live at home and do the things she wants to do, including volunteering, giving back to the community, and doing the everyday things she needs to do to be independent. “I hope to be even more independent. . . I want to help families and individuals navigate the system to obtain the services they need.”
The Department has filed briefs in support of private suits challenging states' refusal to provide community services to people with physical disabilities in order to keep them out of nursing homes. These are the stories of a few of the people who are living in their communities as a result.
At age 47, Michele was struck by a drunk driver while riding her motorcycle, and she became quadriplegic. While in the hospital, she applied for Florida’s spinal cord injury Medicaid Waiver program to get services in her home. But when she got word that she would have to wait about five years before getting services, the future seemed dim. “After my accident it was vitally important for me to quickly get back into a routine and become integrated back into society, and I was anxious to be at home in my familiar environment.”
Because her family was able to provide around-the-clock care, she was able to live at home. But when her personal circumstances changed and she no longer had all of the support she needed to avoid placement in a nursing home, Michele tried again to get community-based services. She was told there were insufficient funds for those services, but that if she entered a nursing home for ninety days, she would become eligible to receive community-based support services to move back out. “I feared that in the process of being forced into a nursing home that I would lose control over my routines, over the things that I enjoyed to do, and essentially be helpless and have less joy in my life.”
Michele filed, and won, a lawsuit under the ADA and Olmstead, requiring the State to provide community-based services without requiring her to first move into a nursing home. DOJ filed a brief in support of her claim. Today, Michele is still living at home with the community-based services she needs.
“Olmstead allowed me to stay at home versus being forced to be institutionalized. To be able to remain in the community means all the difference in the world. It gives me the freedom to live as normal of a life as I possibly can after my life altering accident.”
After she broke her neck and back in a 1989 automobile accident, Nena became paralyzed and uses a power wheelchair. She has a neurogenic bladder and bowel and relies on the use of incontinence supplies. Realizing that her parents were getting older and one day would not be able to care for her, she made the decision to live independently.
“I wanted to know that I could make it on my own.” And she could. She went to college, received a degree in accounting, got married, and raised a daughter. But when her personal circumstances changed and she could no longer afford the costly incontinence supplies, she was faced with some tough decisions—cut back on the use of supplies or default on her bills. She tried to stretch her resources by cutting back on supplies, but developed infections, abscesses, and was frequently on antibiotics.
Nena met with state legislators and advocated for six years to persuade the State to assist with the cost of the incontinence supplies. However, the Missouri Medicaid program refused to cover the cost unless she was in a nursing home. “We were told several times that they would only be covered if I lived in a nursing home.”
Fearing that the only way to receive the supplies she needed was to move to a nursing home and lose her independence, Nena, and several others in the same situation, filed suit and DOJ filed a brief in support of their claim. The federal district court agreed that the State had violated the ADA, and that under Olmstead, the State was required to provide incontinence supplies to adults who needed them in the community.
“Olmstead opened up a world for people like me who were trapped. I’m fifty-one years old and I don’t trap well. I hunt, I fish, and I’ve taught both of my granddaughters. Everything that my parents and my grandparents did with me, I do with them. I consider it very important; it helps build strong family values. That is something that I could not do from a nursing home. ”